Advertisement
Advertisement
Legislative Council of Hong Kong
Get more with myNEWS
A personalised news feed of stories that matter to you
Learn more
Pro-democracy activists collect signatures in Tin Shui Wai hours before the nomination period for the Legislative Council election closed on July 31. The same day, the election was put off for a year citing Covid-19 health risks. Photo: Edmond So

Letters | Hong Kong Legco election: why Carrie Lam’s claims on putting off vote ring hollow

Following her announcement last Friday that the Legislative Council general election would be postponed for a year, a reporter asked Chief Executive Carrie Lam Cheng Yuet-ngor if she was concerned about how her decision would look to the outside world after the year of protests. She replied, in no uncertain terms, that her decision had nothing to do with politics or the likely outcome of the elections.

Does anybody believe her? No one doubts that holding a general election during a pandemic poses a public health risk. But to say she was not reminded of the 2019 District Council election results during the decision-making process, or never once turned her mind towards throwing her pro-Beijing compatriots a lifeline, somehow rings hollow.

It is also unsurprising that to postpone the elections, Lam again resorted to a remnant of the colonial era, the Emergency Regulations Ordinance. That piece of legislation had lain dormant since the 1970s but was brought back to life only nine months ago, to allow her to enact the 2019 anti-mask law.

03:39

Hong Kong Legislative Council elections postponed by a year

Hong Kong Legislative Council elections postponed by a year
This time, Lam’s position – and presumably her confidence – was plainly bolstered by the fact she could rely on and even cite the Court of Appeal judgment in April. The judgment stated that the chief executive is empowered under that law to make emergency regulations on any occasion of public danger.
Was Lam’s decision to postpone the election made in the public interest? Remember that Covid-19 was first confirmed to have spread to Hong Kong more than six months ago. We are now in the third, albeit most serious, wave of the pandemic. In addition, the Legco general election had been a long time coming.
Did the Hong Kong government have a plan B? Why was Singapore – where the number of confirmed cases far exceeds that in Hong Kong – able to hold a general election on July 10?

Lam described her decision as the hardest she has had to make since the coronavirus first hit Hong Kong. One can’t help but think it was actually the easiest.

Jeremy Lee, Lantau

Post