Advertisement
Coronavirus pandemic
OpinionLetters

Letters | Hong Kong coronavirus testing scheme: 12-hour shifts are a disgrace

  • That staff had to work long hours, wear diapers to forgo toilet breaks and experienced muscle soreness indicate poor programme design

Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Health experts from mainland China on duty at Sun Yat Sen Memorial Park Sports Centre in Sai Ying Pun where a temporary air-inflated experimental laboratory was set up for Covid-19 testing, on September 12. Photo: Xiaomei Chen
Letters
Your report of September 13, “Muscle ache, diapers all in a day’s work”, was truly shocking, assuming that the facts can be verified as stated.

To think that any organisation, let alone a government body devoted to health, could countenance staff working for 12 hours, and up to eight hours without a toilet break and thus feeling obliged to wear diapers, is truly astounding.

The hygiene implications in a supposedly clean-room laboratory environment are hard to exaggerate, let alone the insult to human dignity involved. I suspect that any private sector employer who allowed this to happen, regardless of whether it was authorised or not, would be investigated and possibly prosecuted by the Labour Department.

Advertisement

Further, that the process for handling the testing involved processes which cause “muscle soreness in [the] shoulders and hands” of staff indicates poor design and insufficient care towards any health and safety assessment which might have been carried out. Was there one?

The workers, and even the processes, may be from the mainland, but the supervision is undeniably the responsibility of the Hong Kong government.

Advertisement
Some weeks ago, there were news reports of the terrible living conditions imposed on workers at the container port during what are apparently extraordinarily long shifts. If this is the price of maintaining competitive rates against mainland ports, then perhaps Hong Kong should just give up this activity. I don’t recall seeing any statement from the Labour Department on the issue so far.
The cramped quarters provided for dock workers to rest in at the Kwai Tsing Container Terminals came to light as a cluster of coronavirus cases was discovered at the port. Photo: Handout
The cramped quarters provided for dock workers to rest in at the Kwai Tsing Container Terminals came to light as a cluster of coronavirus cases was discovered at the port. Photo: Handout
Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x