-
Advertisement
Hong Kong environmental issues
OpinionLetters

Letters | Don’t waste public money ‘cleaning up’ Hong Kong’s Cadogan park

  • A recent test shows safe levels of pollutants in soil at the park. The government should not base its decision to conduct soil decontamination work on an assessment 20 years ago

2-MIN READ2-MIN
A campaign event was held on May 2, 2016 calling for the conservation of Cadogan Street Temporary Garden in Kennedy Town. The park was saved after the Town Planning Board rezoned the land “open space”. Photo: Dickson Lee
Letters

Since 2017, the Town Planning Board has designated the Cadogan Street Temporary Garden in Kennedy Town an “open space” in land use zoning, so it has continued to serve the community as a park.

Since then, members of the local community and some scholars have also requested the Civil Engineering and Development Department to remove the garden site from the scope of its Kennedy Town decontamination project.

We point out that the soil at the site does not need to be decontaminated and the park should in fact be kept open for public use during soil decontamination in nearby areas, to serve as a filtration barrier to protect users’ health.
Advertisement

Sadly, the department has insisted that soil decontamination is necessary at the Cadogan garden, based on an environmental impact assessment done around 20 years ago, without retesting the soil to ascertain whether decontamination is needed now.

The department also indicated that the decontamination site will be 3 metres deep, which is much more than the depth of the surface soil (around 1 metre) required for decontamination, according to international standards.

Advertisement
Cadogan Street Temporary Garden in Kennedy Town seen in May 2016. The Civil Engineering and Development Department has included the park in its soil decontamination project in Kennedy Town. Photo: Xiaomei Chen
Cadogan Street Temporary Garden in Kennedy Town seen in May 2016. The Civil Engineering and Development Department has included the park in its soil decontamination project in Kennedy Town. Photo: Xiaomei Chen
Advertisement
Select Voice
Select Speed
1.00x