Advertisement
Hong Kong healthcare and hospitals
OpinionLetters

Letters | Foreign medical graduates are welcome in Hong Kong, but don’t blame local doctors for health policy failures

  • Local doctors have every incentive to ease pressure on Hong Kong’s overstretched health care system, but a dual-track system for entry would work better

Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Hong Kong medical students queue to have their temperature checked before sitting an exam at the School of Public Health in Prince of Wales Hospital in Sha Tin on April 3, 2020. Photo: Nora Tam
Letters

Olivia, the Hong Kong-born daughter of a surgical colleague, is a young neurologist working in Singapore. She graduated from London a few years ago and, having settled down there, she didn’t care much to return. But last year she received a job offer to move either to Singapore or Hong Kong.

Home had nostalgic appeal, but there was no guarantee she would obtain a full licence and be able to complete her specialty training in Hong Kong – she would not be the same as the rest of us unless she passed the licensing examination. Why bother? She picked Singapore.

Jeremy is a gastroenterologist. We worked together for years. Having scored top marks in his school certificate exam back in the 1980s, he won a scholarship to study medicine in Cambridge. He later returned to become one of us without examination. Had a licensing exam been required, he would certainly have passed it with flying colours, but why would he have come here had there been more inviting choices? Are we losing international vision?

We welcome foreign medical graduates provided they are up to standard, but is one local examination the only acceptable standard?

Advertisement
Chief Executive Carrie Lam in February unveiled plans to introduce foreign medical graduates here by bypassing the licensing examination, a reform she described last November as “a war that must be fought” with the medical profession, implying the oft-quoted “protectionism”.
Officials pointed to our relatively low doctor-to-population ratio, quoted a shortfall of 660 doctors in the Hospital Authority alone, attributed the long waiting time for public specialty services mainly to doctor shortage, and forecast a staggering shortfall of 1,949 doctors by 2040.
Advertisement

But doctors suffer too when the waiting time is long: the workload is incredible.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x