-
Advertisement
Coronavirus Hong Kong
OpinionLetters

Letters | Back up Hong Kong’s 21-day hotel quarantine rule with clear data

  • Hong Kong officials should be transparent with the public about how many fully vaccinated persons who tested negative for Covid-19 on arrival ended up developing the coronavirus disease while in quarantine

Reading Time:1 minute
Why you can trust SCMP
6
Arriving travellers wait to be transported to quarantine hotels at Hong Kong airport on June 30. Photo: Felix Wong
Letters

Dear Dr Constance Chan JP, director of health,

May I inquire on a subject which, as a self-employed person, I have been struggling to comprehend?

Being a permanent Hong Kong resident, fully vaccinated and having tested negative for Covid-19 with standard recognised tests, we are still subject to hotel quarantine upon arrival from overseas, which comes at a considerable cost to us small and medium-sized business operators, putting heavy constraints on our ability to fully earn our livelihood.

Advertisement

In the interest of public health during a pandemic, preventive measures are certainly justified, but how can a hotel quarantine be a better, more safe and justifiable means of preventing community spread of Covid-19 compared to home quarantine, especially when we are fully vaccinated and test negative upon arrival?

How many fully vaccinated Hong Kong residents with negative test results have gone on to turn Covid-positive during the mandatory hotel quarantine? Can we have some statistics here please, as this would certainly shed light on the question of balancing the cost to society in burdening individuals with avoidable costs?

03:02

Returnees fight cabin fever during mandatory 21-day hotel quarantine in Hong Kong

Returnees fight cabin fever during mandatory 21-day hotel quarantine in Hong Kong
I would venture that the number is in the single digits and consists only of unvaccinated inbound travellers, and this does not justify the current way of handling the arrival of Hongkongers.
Advertisement
Select Voice
Select Speed
1.00x