Advertisement
Hong Kong national security law
OpinionLetters

Letters | Hong Kong’s national security law conviction: what our readers think

  • In addition to the case dealing with the national security law, our readers share their thoughts on the pressure to get vaccinated and panda diplomacy

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
A prison van carrying Tong Ying-kit, the first person charged under the new national security law, leaves the High Court after Tong was sentenced to nine years in prison on July 30. Photo: Reuters
Letters

Nine years for dangerous driving with a tatty banner

The sentence handed down to Leon Tong Ying-kit for terrorism and secession was not only harsh, it was totally out of proportion to what he did: driving recklessly and flying a flag bearing what the judges deemed to be a separatist slogan.

During the 1970s, I did several spells of work in Northern Ireland where terrorism was a hideous and inescapable fact of everyday life. And by “terrorism” I mean what my dictionary says it is: using violent and intimidating methods … to achieve political ends.

Advertisement

In Northern Ireland, violence included, for example, shooting parents dead in front of their children and planting bombs in busy shopping centres, not to mention the often bloody assassinations of police, politicians and public servants. Hardly the Hong Kong which we know and are fortunate to live in today.

Had this case come before a Northern Ireland court at the time, my guess is that Mr Tong would have been given a severe dressing down by the judge for committing the serious crime of dangerous driving and sentenced to a couple of years in prison. As for the flag, I doubt whether the court would have given the matter more than 10 minutes’ consideration despite Northern Ireland’s current strict security laws.

Advertisement
The hard-pressed police had better things to do (like nabbing bombers and gunmen) than squander time and money dragging to court everybody displaying some item or other which might, just might, be against the law. But in today’s Hong Kong, we are, by contrast, treated to the laughable spectacle of academics solemnly offering different meanings for the essentially meaningless words on Mr Tong’s tatty banner.
Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x