-
Advertisement
Coronavirus Hong Kong
OpinionLetters

Letters | Is Hong Kong’s 21-day quarantine worth the cost in the long term?

  • Readers discuss the city’s lengthy quarantine requirements, the proposed ban on e-cigarettes, and air mail services to the UK

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
3
A person undergoing quarantine relaxes in his room in a government-designated hotel in Hong Kong on  August 18. Photo: EPA-EFE
Letters
I should first declare my personal interest in arguing for Hong Kong to consider relaxing its stringent travel restrictions: it has been over one year and nine months since I last saw my family. In this time, my grandmother, whom I am extremely close to, has had two health scares.

I have had my wedding postponed twice because my fiancé, who is British, is unable to enter Hong Kong, and we would lose the deposit we paid our Hong Kong wedding vendors if we cancelled. To say that the restrictions have had an emotional and psychological toll on me would be an understatement.

I have worked on the front lines at the height of the pandemic, as a medical doctor in Britain. I understand and have seen first-hand the risk that Covid-19 poses, and the harm it could cause. However, I am increasingly frustrated by the Hong Kong government’s decision to impose such draconian travel restrictions when they are not based on scientific evidence, and which are causing travellers and its population harm.

Advertisement
There is no evidence that 21 days of hotel quarantine offer more protection and benefit than 14 days. It is well documented that the incubation period for Sars-CoV-2 is up to 14 days. There is good evidence that quarantine can cause depression and post-traumatic stress symptoms. Children are especially vulnerable; post-traumatic stress scores were four times higher for children who underwent quarantine than those who did not.

A longer quarantine is, unsurprisingly, associated with poorer mental health. Given the financial and psychological impact of quarantine, is 21 days of hotel quarantine for travellers really necessary?

Advertisement

The Hong Kong government should take into account the long-term consequences of its extreme travel restrictions and mandatory hotel quarantine, and base their implementation on scientific evidence.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Select Speed
1.00x