Advertisement
Coronavirus Hong Kong
OpinionLetters

Letters | Nine ways to improve Hong Kong’s Covid-19 strategy and reopen borders

  • Readers suggest a more sustainable path out of the pandemic, question the lack of social distancing in Covid-19 testing queues, and wonder why ‘partygate’ lawmakers can’t take responsibility

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
2
People queue for a Covid-19 test a community centre in Tuen Mun on January 13. Photo: May Tse
Letters
As a result of Hong Kong’s zero-Covid strategy, which it has pursued as part of efforts to reopen our borders more quickly, we have been well protected so far. However, the science behind the infections and the extent of the spread of Omicron globally might suggest zero-Covid could take months, if not years, to achieve – at the expense of the economy and our children.

Perhaps there’s another way to achieve our epidemic-prevention goal more quickly and sustainably which would require an amendment to the implementation of protective measures and the redeployment of resources as follows, if we don’t want to move to “mandatory vaccines”.
First, ask the vulnerable, elderly and unvaccinated to continue to isolate at home, supported by family, who may also need to isolate themselves.

Second, repurpose Penny’s Bay, holiday villages or North Lantau Hospital for those who cannot effectively isolate at home due to living conditions and redeploy testing resources to support them.

Third, allow companies to advise or impose restrictions based on their operating model – to keep businesses running. Some are moving to mandatory vaccination, others do weekly testing for the unvaccinated to come to work.

Fourth, reopen all public facilities and keep children in school. Retain mask wearing and social distancing. Continue with all restrictions for the unvaccinated without exemption.

Fifth, as Covid-19 re-enters the community, home quarantine will be required – only if very sick would one go to hospital – making sure beds are only for the very ill. Largely, people would be isolating at home or in Penny’s Bay.

02:07

Singapore adds 8 more countries to quarantine-free list for vaccinated travellers

Singapore adds 8 more countries to quarantine-free list for vaccinated travellers

Sixth, no more community testing or lockdown required as we expect to get Covid-19 based on the spread overseas. Redeploy resources to support hospitals and Penny’s Bay.

Seventh, stop putting close contacts in Penny’s Bay. Ask them to isolate at home. While some will have Covid-19, the rates will be spread out.

Eighth, remove all flight bans immediately as the airline-specific ones don’t really make sense.

Last but not least, reduce all quarantine to 10 days in line with the science and move quickly to zero-quarantine once we know we can manage the hospital numbers.

Although a reversal of the current model, these steps will help achieve the same goal and are more sustainable as they will enable us to achieve herd immunity quicker, possibly remove vaccine hesitancy, and protect the vulnerable.

Advertisement

Tina Atkinson, Pok Fu Lam

Are we ready for a testing queue cluster?

The long queues formed for Covid-19 testing have no social distancing whatsoever. Waiting one behind the other for hours on end, no toilet available, is hard for everybody, especially the elderly. Why is there no fast lane for older residents?
Advertisement
Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x