Advertisement
US-China relations
Opinion
Tom Plate

Opinion | Why China and the US need to worry about the war on think tanks and free thought

  • Xi Jinping’s discomfort with the pluralism of think tanks is matched by the US distrust of Confucius Institutes and Chinese students
  • Policy intellectuals are increasingly needed in a complex world, and it is the high responsibility of Beijing and Washington to keep the conversation flowing

Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Illustration: Craig Stephens

Right, you don’t have to remind me: the Chinese civilisation of 3,000-plus years has at the ready ancient sayings for almost everything that comes up in life – sort of like the French who “always have a word for it”.

Well, we Americans are not voiceless ninnies without our own cultural verbiage, and, for what I am about to argue, our best insipid phrase would be something like “Don’t Throw the Baby Out With the Bathwater” or “Look Before You Leap” … you get the idea.

Here’s the policy point: consider for a moment the think tank, a seemingly non-glamorous dull-as-dishwater subject. But it’s not: in such a tank, the sharpest sharks of the human mindset swim probingly, relentlessly, hungrily. For such intellectual jaws, America is rightly famous – the daunting Rand Corporation on our West Coast, the influential Centre for Strategic and International Studies on the East, and so on.

Advertisement
But in China? Surprise! Although often knocked by Western sociologists for having a civil society that’s pathetically paper-thin, China does have countless think tanks. Many add invaluable depth to Chinese public policy that help drive the country’s economic development in sane directions.
Instead of mindlessly measuring China’s development in terms of “black GDP numbers”, think-tank thinker Hu Angang, wily but controversial, pushes for a new metric of “green GDP” growth. Environmentalists around the world offer praise for “Chairman” Xi Jinping’s emphasis on this transcendent and possibly existential challenge, especially in comparison to America’s Donald J Trump, who appears oblivious to all evidence, from US think tanks or anywhere else.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x