Advertisement
Coronavirus pandemic
Opinion
Tom Plate

Opinion | Trump’s America and Xi’s China are dangerously stuck in a rut

  • Both Beijing and Washington are retreating to old patterns – of US-bashing or China-bashing. The two countries must move away from rivalry and understand their differences as problems that have solutions

Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Illustration: Craig Stephens

Many of us have just been through a lockdown, and some of us are still stuck in it. Prior to the Covid-19 pandemic, the term usually meant the kind of harsh confinement that would befall inmates of a penal institution in the wake of a prison riot. Slight parallels with what we non-felons have endured lately are obvious.

Recall the warning from one of the greats, literary immortal E.M. Forster. In his short story The Machine Stops, the English author of A Passage to India conjures up a world in which humans hunker down in underground bunker rooms – sustained by food deliveries and a take-charge, in-room communication machine that is the primary link to others. One utterly predictable result was limited thinking.

Forster’s vision was that confinement and technology would render people one-dimensional, having the same recycled conversations and ideas. This knockout of a lockdown story was published in 1909.

Advertisement
Let’s pull Foster’s prescient mindscape into our present-day life of the internet, videoconferencing and globalisation. How can we expect the world today to advance using the same old approaches? Global problems snake around us like hordes of boa constrictors; as if lacking courage, national leaders, for the most part, hunker down in mental lockdown, leaving human-made technology to do the intellectual processing of solutions to problems mainly created by human-made technology. Conventional, mechanistic answers can hardly solve daunting new problems.

If there is a better illustration of mental lockdown than ferociously fraught US-China relations, I am unaware of it. Both so-called superpowers are in trouble. Nightly, you witness scenes of urban implosion in the United States. China, though much harder to assess, may be in deep trouble as well. Who knows?

Just the other day, an admirably candid Premier Li Keqiang blew everyone’s mind when he admitted that, despite his country’s internationally applauded economic resurrection, about two out of every five people in China still have to squeeze by on something like US$140 a month! In America, a substantial population remains stuck in poverty no matter which of the two parties are in office.
Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x