Advertisement
Inside Out & Outside In
Opinion
David Dodwell

Inside OutCoronavirus hastening a global fight over taxes on carbon and digital services

  • Governments around the world looking for new revenue sources are targeting tech giants, most of which are American, for taxes, at the risk of Trump’s wrath
  • EU’s plan to tax carbon at its borders also threatens to launch a new trade war with the US

4-MIN READ4-MIN
US President Donald Trump (right) at a G7 meeting last August. He has threatened to retaliate with tariffs if countries unilaterally introduce carbon or digital services taxes. Photo: AFP
Taxes may be tedious, but that certainly does not stop them from being controversial. Take the rows simmering between the European Union and the United States over carbon taxes and digital services taxes.

From an outsider’s point of view, both of these proposed new taxes seem eminently fair and sensible. As the awesome costs of battling and recovering from the global pandemic start to become clear, such new sources of government income must also surely be welcome. Efforts to get agreements at a global level have been ambitious but not unreasonable. But predictably and unhelpfully, the US disagrees.

The US has withdrawn from digital services tax negotiations, and threatens to punish any country that introduces taxes without their agreement. The row over carbon taxes is just warming up.
Advertisement

The digital services tax has been simmering harder and longer, as an increasing number of European governments have railed against the largely-US technology giants that have captured such large shares of their consumer economies while successfully avoiding any significant local tax contributions.

As local bricks-and-mortar companies have struggled in the face of the inroads being made by the likes of Google and Amazon , and as tax revenues have shrunk while pandemic-related costs soar, so the passion to capture more income from the tech giants has intensified.

Efforts by the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development to broker a multilateral deal – surely better than a mess of potentially conflicting unilateral digital tax laws – have been patient and protracted. But they have become increasingly forlorn as the patience of countries such as France, Italy, Spain and Britain have worn thin as their need for new tax revenue mount, and as the US presidential election approaches.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Select Speed
1.00x