-
Advertisement
Hong Kong coronavirus fourth wave
Opinion
Mike Rowse

Opinion | Repeated government failures to get to grips with Covid-19 are hurting Hong Kong

  • The impression is of a huge gap between strategic decision-making at the top and conditions on the ground
  • There is no evidence of a proper monitoring system to identify problems; rather, officials appear to be making ad hoc decisions in response to individual events

Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
People queue up for Covid-19 testing at a community centre in Yau Ma Tei, on December 12, as the fourth wave of the pandemic continues to surge in Hong Kong. Photo: Xiaomei Chen

Not surprisingly, the subject of Covid-19 has attracted considerable media coverage for most of this year. As someone who closely studies the print media, and who co-hosts a talk show on RTHK each week, I naturally get to hear and read a lot about the pandemic.

What is surprising is how often I am surprised by new nuggets of information. For example, in mid-August, then-Legislative Council member Kwok Ka-ki told a radio audience that some 300,000 people were exempt from health checks at the border and allowed to freely enter Hong Kong.

Dr Kwok blamed this policy for a previous surge in virus cases here, and contrasted Hong Kong’s practices with those adopted by the mainland and our neighbouring special administrative region, Macau, both of which were being much more successful in controlling the spread of the disease.
Advertisement
I put Kwok’s statistic to other guests on the show in subsequent weeks and it was never challenged. Moreover, nobody from the government, which monitors the media, felt obliged to come on air and offer different numbers. Some exemptions involving pilots and ships’ crews have since been withdrawn but, at the border, many tens of thousands of arrivals still enter untested.

In subsequent weeks, other worrying information came to light. For example, many of those returning to Hong Kong from overseas who were subject to quarantine were allowed to do so at home. Only officials living in large flats with multiple bathrooms could believe this was going to be effective.

04:29

Hong Kong cage home resident finds space too small for self-quarantine amid coronavirus outbreak

Hong Kong cage home resident finds space too small for self-quarantine amid coronavirus outbreak

In average households, it would be impossible to avoid close contact with other family members – all of whom were free to wonder the streets and mingle with the community.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x