Advertisement
US-China relations
Opinion
Tom Plate

Opinion | Lessons from the Alaska summit: both the US and China must rethink their diplomacy

  • Beijing’s diplomacy vis-à-vis the US too often sounds like a broken record. A dynamic, mostly improving China should have more to offer
  • Meanwhile, American diplomats seem utterly flummoxed by Beijing, and risk aiming at old China ghosts rather than new realities

Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
5
Illustration: Craig Stephens
The future is not always all that tough to predict: “Should both Pacific powers remain frozen in stereotype, high-level diplomacy may yield next to nothing, or worse”. That was my fearless view last month. It remains the view today in the aftermath of the Alaska summit where otherwise seasoned American and Chinese diplomats produced ditsy diplomacy for all the world to see. 
The setting for the rhetorical snowball fight was a hotel conference room in Anchorage, where March temperatures even by noon are barely above freezing – just about right for the new cold war.

Struggling with the Covid-19 pandemic and the continuing climate crisis, the world would cheer any degree of relief from bad news. But a roaring quarrel between the two biggest elephants in any jungle is bound to set the nerves of the other animals on edge. 

Advertisement

At a time when China’s economy is setting modern records, Beijing’s diplomacy vis-à-vis the US too often sounds like a broken record. There’s plenty of fault on both sides, but let’s start with the psyche of contemporary Chinese diplomacy. Rooted in a mausoleum of past resentment and score-setting, it has scant room to breathe.

At the very moment when many countries are convinced China should have all sorts of new things to say, it throws up Xi Jinping Thought as if that’s all the thinking required.
Advertisement

Historically, China may offer a most comfortable cultural couch for a sitting emperor, but today’s reality is a dynamic, mostly improving Chinese society, more or less plugged into the outside world, creating pressures on the old to accept new ways. The Communist Party needs to be smarter than ever. 

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x