-
Advertisement
Afghanistan
Opinion
Tom Plate

Opinion | Afghanistan and beyond: China must learn from US hubris and blunders

  • The tragedy of Afghanistan has made clear that the US is no longer the ‘indispensable nation’
  • Let’s hope that China, which so resents being lectured by the US, won’t make the same arrogant mistakes overseas as America

Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
6
Illustration: Stephen Case
The agony in Afghanistan makes for many sorrows. Beyond the scenes of chaos at Kabul airport is the unseen anguish of all those US veterans back home who are dealing with various psychological and physical traumas and are now especially unproud of their country; of families who have unnecessarily lost sons and daughters; and of young Americans who might reasonably fear a future of more wars ending in anger.

The tragic lesson of Vietnam – yes, America should have learned; the similar lesson of Afghanistan – yes, America should have learned; but we did not.

I can particularly relate to college graduates studying in the US and abroad at public policy schools and international politics programmes; the idealism in their hearts is curbed by the realism in their heads.

Advertisement
As future diplomats and internationalists, will they also wind up ferrying refugees out of airports in the shadow of death? Surely this is not remotely what anyone of good will meant in describing the United States, until very recently, as the “indispensable nation”.

In today’s world, there is no such thing as an indispensable nation, and now that we can forever retire that moniker on the altar of Kabul airport, let me add that my Chinese friends who might dare to imagine their nation as next up for the honour are doing their country a great disservice.

Advertisement

Hubris on that scale would be the beginning of a downfall. The East can always learn from the West, which has made enough errors of judgment and misplaced enough priorities as to offer the world a manual in what not to do.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x