Advertisement
China economy
Opinion
Nicholas Spiro

Macroscope | China’s zero-Covid policy is thwarting efforts to stabilise the economy

  • Beijing is trying to simultaneously pursue a zero-tolerance approach to Covid-19, reduce debt exposure and ease monetary policy to boost growth
  • These policies contradict each other, though, and draconian, growth-sapping lockdowns stand in the way of rebuilding consumer and investor confidence

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
44
Security guards in protective gear staff a checkpoint as several city blocks are sealed off because of Covid-19 in the Meilong township of Shanghai on August 15. Photo: Bloomberg
For an indication of the scale of the challenge confronting China’s slowing economy, look no further than the pandemonium at an Ikea outlet in Shanghai last Saturday. The sudden announcement of a snap lockdown of the store sent shoppers fleeing and screaming as they sought to leave the building before the doors were locked.

Never mind that a durable recovery hinges on Chinese consumers’ ability and willingness to spend. The revelation that a close contact of a six-year-old boy with an asymptomatic case of Covid-19 had visited the store recently was enough for Shanghai’s government to impose an immediate two-day quarantine, followed by five days of health monitoring of those affected.

Sowing panic among consumers and businesses is the price China is willing to pay to maintain its zero-tolerance approach to the virus. Public health objectives – which reflect the government’s unwavering resolve to avoid mass fatalities in a nation with relatively low vaccination rates among the elderly and less effective vaccines – have long trumped economic goals.
Advertisement

However, managing the trade-off between fighting the virus and inflicting economic harm has become exceptionally difficult, so much so that the policy response to the downturn is increasingly ineffective. China is caught in an economic trap of its own making.

Last Friday, the People’s Bank of China (PBOC) published data showing that a measure of broad-based money supply known as M2 accelerated to a stronger-than-expected annualised 12 per cent last month, pointing to ample liquidity in the financial system. Yet, aggregate social financing – a broad gauge of credit growth – slowed to 10.7 per cent, held back by a deceleration in the growth of loans to households and companies.

01:52

Shanghai Ikea shoppers scramble for the exits during flash Covid shutdown

Shanghai Ikea shoppers scramble for the exits during flash Covid shutdown
The mismatch between a banking system flush with cash and a slowdown in lending points to a liquidity trap. This is when, no matter how low interest rates are, consumers and businesses are reluctant to borrow while banks are wary of lending.
Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x