Advertisement

Macroscope | Why China’s dominance puts Brics expansion plans and very existence in jeopardy

  • The differences in fortunes between China and the other Brics members are complicating plans for expansion and challenging the US dollar
  • The more dependent the group is on China, the deeper the fault lines within the bloc and the more difficult it is to coordinate policy

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
30
A resident looks out towards the skyline of the central business district in Johannesburg, South Africa, on August 15. The Brics summit will take place in the city from August 22-24, with plans to expand the bloc’s membership encountering resistance over concerns about diluting influence and complicating policymaking. Photo: Bloomberg
In an interview with the Financial Times earlier this week, Jim O’Neill, the former Goldman Sachs chief economist who coined the Brics acronym in 2001, said the group of five leading emerging markets had “never achieved anything” since it began holding annual summits in 2009.

This is a damning verdict from the economist who grouped together the developing nations of Brazil, Russia, India and China – South Africa joined in 2010 – because of their role in driving growth, a far-reaching shift that, according to O’Neill, required a more representative form of global governance.

Moreover, it comes at an awkward time for the bloc, whose leaders are preparing to hold their 15th summit in Johannesburg. Not only is there increasing interest from other developing countries in joining the club, Brazilian President Lula da Silva has also urged the group to establish a common currency to take on the dominance of the US dollar.
Advertisement

Brics has come a long way since the turn of the century. As Bank of America noted in a report published on August 11, the Brics nations’ combined gross domestic product as a share of global output surpassed that of the Group of 7 advanced economies in 2021 in purchasing power parity terms. By 2028, the Brics countries are expected to account for 33.6 per cent of global output, compared with 27 per cent for the G7.

Furthermore, the bloc is united in its resentment against US financial hegemony, a bitterness that intensified following Washington’s moves to punish Russia for its invasion of Ukraine. However, the defiant rhetoric fails to mask the absence of policy coordination to increase the group’s collective power and influence on the global stage.

04:00

Brazil’s President Lula meets with Xi, seeks to expand trade, Chinese investments and talk Ukraine

Brazil’s President Lula meets with Xi, seeks to expand trade, Chinese investments and talk Ukraine

At the root of the club’s lack of cohesion is the overwhelming dominance of China, the only Brics member that has made meaningful progress in converging with the developed world by becoming a knowledge-based and data-driven economy.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x