bodyType

customContents

entityId

entityUuid

articlePageQuery

filter

article

articleBaseAdvertisingInfoArticle

articleListArticle

articleSeoArticle

hooksArticleAcknowledgementGateOverlayArticle

hooksTrackPageViewArticle

hooksContentInterestArticle

articleLinkingDataContent

hooksAmpRedirectArticle

articleSchemaContent

liveArticle

advertZone

sentiment

contentLock

topics

types

sections

paywallTypes

createdDate

publishedDate

urlAlias

moreOnThisArticles

sponsorType

commentCount

authorLocations

authors

corrections

displaySlideShow

multimediaEmbed

printHeadline

seriesContainer

articleSpeeches

socialHeadline

headline

images

flag

firstTopic

glossary

flattenTypeIds

image

relatedLinks

relatedNewsletters

__typename

sponsor

pdfFiles

seriesReverseOrder

series

disableOffPlatformContent

published

updatedDate

summary

subHeadline

body

keywords

readingTime

customTimezone

liveContents

Francis P Sempa

 
The China Mission: George Marshall’s Unfinished War, 1945-1947
by Daniel Kurtz-Phelan
WW Norton
4/5 stars
The title of Daniel Kurtz-Phelan’s new book about US general George Marshall’s efforts to bring about peace between the Nationalists and Communists in China after the end of the second world war should be “The Impossible China Mission”. Marshall’s ill-fated mission was the product of wishful thinking and hubris on the part of policymakers in the Truman administration.
Marshall’s mission to China was a manifestation of a recurring and troubling strain of American foreign policy: the idea that the United States can remake other countries in its own image.
It is an idea that has resulted in colossal foreign policy failures, most recently in President George W. Bush’s disastrous effort to democratise Iraq and spread American values and institutions to Arab nations in the Middle East.
Its greatest failure, however, was in China after the second world war.
How China censors its internet and controls information, from Great Firewall to 50 Cent Army: two new books explain
Kurtz-Phelan, the executive editor of Foreign Affairs and a former US State Department policy planner, is an unabashed admirer of General Marshall. He refers to him as “the greatest of the Greatest Generation” in American history.
There is a touch of hagiography here. Marshall, to be sure, accomplished and achieved much in his career. He was a brilliant staff officer in the first world war, the “organiser of victory” in the second world war, the symbol of the successful post-war European Recovery Programme that bears his name (the Marshall Plan), and served as both secretary of state and secretary of defence in the Truman administration.
But even as great an admirer as Kurtz-Phelan recognises that “the common understanding of Marshall and his accomplishments has tended to leave out his time in China altogether”.
China, as the author notes, was touted by FDR during the war as an expected partner of the Allies in building a peaceful post-war world. Instead, it descended into civil war and ultimately communist rule, with terrible consequences for the Chinese people and US foreign policy.
China’s online publishing industry – where fortune favours the few, and sometimes the undeserving
This was not Marshall’s fault. The Nationalists under Chiang Kai-shek and the Communists under Mao Zedong were never going to reach a compromise. The failure of US policy – which Marshall was charged with implementing – was the failure to recognise that reality and conduct foreign policy accordingly.
This failure was compounded by the Truman administration’s insistence that the Nationalists become democrats and invite the Communists to share power in a coalition government.
Marshall spent 13 months shuttling between Chiang and Mao (often represented by Zhou Enlai), acting not as an ally of the Chinese government, but as a neutral, honest broker between the government and the Communists. Yet Chiang was America’s ally.
The US supplied his government with arms and advisers. Chiang could never quite understand or accept that his ally would abandon his government to the Communists who were, after all, the ally of America’s chief adversary, the Soviet Union.
Kelly Yang mines her experience as child immigrant in US for touching debut novel
Kurtz-Phelan’s account places equal blame for the failure of Marshall’s mission on Nationalist and Communist “hardliners”. But that misses the point. Marshall’s mission was doomed before it began. As James Burnham and others pointed out at the time and later, even before the guns of the second world war fell silent, communist forces in China shifted their focus from fighting Japan to preparing for the post-war struggle for power.
The Truman administration’s policy, which would be repeated with similar results by future US administrations in Southeast Asia in the 1960s, in Central America and Iran in the late 1970s, and, more recently, in Egypt and other parts of the Arab world, pressured Chiang to institute democratic reforms during a civil war against opponents who were unconstrained by democratic norms and practices. The goal was to unify China under liberal democratic rule.
The author notes that by 1947, Chiang’s forces controlled almost 80 per cent of China. Chiang thought he was on the cusp of victory. That, too, was an illusion. And as US support for the Nationalists waned, Soviet support for the Communists increased. In the end, the Communists won and founded the People’s Republic of China on 1 October 1949.
China undermining Australian democracy, writes professor of public ethics in Silent Invasion: China’s Influence in Australia
Americans, meanwhile, debated “who lost China”.
Marshall came home to become secretary of state (and later secretary of defence), where he helped Truman devise and implement policies that resisted Soviet encroachments in Europe.
The administration’s record in Asia, however, was far less successful. China became an adversary and enemy for more than 20 years until president Richard Nixon skilfully exploited the Sino-Soviet split to America’s (and China’s) geopolitical advantage.
The China Mission is an important reminder about the limits of American diplomacy. Marshall, like many US statesmen before and after him, fell prey to the idea that the rest of the world could be persuaded to solve disputes through an American lens.
As Kurtz-Phelan writes: “For all [Marshall’s] efforts to see the world through negotiating partners’ eyes, he did not quite bridge the divide in world views, with clashing notions of power that were in the end irreconcilable.”


China urged to sue over Japanese royal’s role in Unit 731 crimes

Fringe view of China’s history sparks official rebuke after going viral online

Chinese archaeologists discover well-preserved section of 2,200-year-old 4-lane highway

China Santa Claus: how Qing dynasty military figure was ‘cutified’ into ‘Father Christmas’

Chinese history

US failure to bring peace to post-war China explained in The China Mission – book review

Mao Zedong (left) and Chiang Kai-shek toast over the banquet table in Chongqing in 1945. Photo: ChinaFotoPress

DFW0NW President Truman shakes hands with Secretary of State George Marshall as Secretary Marshall is about to leave on an... 199676

From December 1949 to February 1950 Chinese president Mao Zedong visited USSR and met Soviet Union leader Josef Stalin. China and USSR sign few agreements concerning economical, industrial and scientific aid and support.

China Mission cover

D98DYH George Calett Marshall (1880-1959) American soldier and military leader., Chief of Staff of the US Army. Appointed Secretary of

Anna Chennault, China-born Washington power broker and hostess, dies at 94

Anna Chennault in 1968, with a portrait of her late husband, Claire Chennault. File photo: AP

Mrs Anna Chennault, an adviser to American President George Bush on Asian affairs, is on a brief visit to Hong Kong.

Anna Chennault, with Richard Nixon and Henry Kissinger, in 1972

Anna Chennault talks on the phone at a hotel during her visit to Hong Kong. The China-born American, widow of legendary Claire Chennault, the commander of the U.S. 14th air fleet who organised a group of American pilots known as "Flying Tigers" to help China fight Japan during World War Two, rides high in the U.S. political arena, rubs shoulders with leaders in China and commands redeem in its archrival Taiwan. Picture taken September 5, 2002. REUTERS/Bobby Yip TO ACCOMPANY FEATURE STORY CHINA-USA-CHENNAULT

The story of a martyr in Mao’s China: executed and her family billed for the bullet

Lian Xi’s book tells the untold tale of Lin Zhao, a Chinese dissident who showed her contempt for Mao’s regime through letters written in her own blood

Xi Lian Photo: Handout

Blood Letters: The untold story of Lin Zhao, A martyr in Mao's China Photo : Handout [POSTMAGAZINE 0429 BOOKS]

Heilongjiang Daily staff denounce a provincial party official in Harbin during the Cultural Revolution, on August 25, 1966.

Young American’s first-hand account of second opium war: bloody battles and ‘hospitable’ Chinese 

The Toey-Wan during the Second Battle of Taku Forts at the mouth of the Peiho River on June 25, 1859, in a lithograph by T.G. Dutton. Picture: courtesy of George W. H. Cautherley

--ONE TIME USE ONLY-- Sketches By George Washington Heard, Circa 1859. Attack by Allied Forces, 1859. China, Taku Fort. CREDIT / Heard Family collection, Baker Library, Harvard Business School

--ONE TIME USE ONLY-- P103 Attack by Allied Forces, 24-25 June 1859. China, Taku Fort. “Courtesy, George W. H. Cautherley” OR “Courtesy, Dr George W. H. Cautherley, OBE”. As for 3) above, I took an original to a good photographic studio in Hong Kong; they worked on it and I can supply the image they gave me in grey-scale (but not sepia). The is the original caption to the engraving, as reproduced in the Illustrated London News (ILN) 24 September 1859, p. 295, is: “Attack by the Allied Forces on the Chinese Fortifications at the Mouth of the Peiho River”. If you use this image and can show this big enough, it could be interesting to include the key, which is as follows (as in n. 11). T Extreme range of fire; Junks for landing parties; French dispatch-boats; American dispatch-boat; Coromandel; French cutter; Nimrod; Starling on the mud; Landing party; Opossum; Kestrel; Janus; Lee (sunk); Banterer; Opossum; Cormorant (sunk); Haughty; Plover (sunk). “Courtesy, George W. H. Cautherley

An engraving of the May 1858 attack on the Taku forts.

Portrait of George Washington Heard, Jr. of Ipswich, Massachusetts. In 1856, Heard, a young American, about 22 years of age, en route to Hong Kong from America joined the American Legation as an attache. Heard would later go on to manage the company Augustine Heard and Company, one of the two largest American China trading companies during the 1840s-1870s period, in Canton, and served as chairman of the Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation in 1870. Courtesy of Skinner, Inc. www.skinnerinc.com [22APRIL2018 FEATURE POST MAGAZINE]

Image, circa 1859 shows the USS Powhatan. The second opium war, 1856-1860. When in 1856, the 1844 US-China Treaty of Wangxia became due for renewal, American envoy to China William B. Reed set out to negotiated new terms of trade, permission for diplomatic residence in Beijing and the extension of religious freedom to Christians. Following the eventual conclusion of these negotiations, in 1859 his successor, the American minister John E. Ward, embarked in Hong Kong for Beijing aboard the USS Powhatan, with the small hired steamer the Toey-Wan in tow, on a mission to ratify what was now known as the Treaty of Tientsin [Tianjin]. [22APRIL2018 FEATURE POST MAGAZINE] Courtesy Gillian Bickley

--ONE TIME USE ONLY-- Peiho Forts CIRCA 1859. P94 CREDIT / Dr George W. H. Cautherley, OBE”

Culture

Books

The Marshall Plan changed post-war Europe, but its architect, General George Marshall, failed to unite China’s Nationalists and Communists. Author Daniel Kurtz-Phelan asserts that US foreign policy was flawed and doomed to failure


An assessment or critique of a service, product or creative endeavour.  Film reviews, restaurant reviews, reviews of art exhibitions. (Eg. Crazy Rich Asians: an important film, yes, but a good one?)


Review

.css-sioo19{color:#c79a00;}Review | US failure to bring peace to post-war China explained in The China Mission – book review

Review | US failure to bring peace to post-war China explained in The China Mission – book review