appConfigEntityId

bodyType

customContents

entityId

entityUuid

isVideo

articlePageQuery

article

articleSchemaContent

content

hooksArticlePageAdvertisementConfigArticle

appConfig

filter

json

liveArticle

Lisa Cam

We are in for a scorching summer – and one of the best ways to beat the heat is to consume a huge bowl of flavoured shaved ice.
Many Asian countries have their versions of the icy treat – ais kacang in Malaysia, chendol in Singapore, nam kang sai in Thailand or baobing in Taiwan, for example – but one of the most popular and well-known around the world is Japan’s kakigori.
This shaved-ice treat is one of the most sought-after desserts when travellers go to Japan in the summer.
Korea also has its own version, called bingsu. But why is it not as popular as kakigori on the world stage?

“I think Japanese shaved ice is definitely in its own category,” says Kaila Imada, owner of the kakigori-focused Instagram account @kakigori.kaila.
Kakigori is made of a base of just pure ice. According to Imada, some shops pride themselves on where their ice comes from, like using natural ice from the Japanese Alps.
The treat is finished off with a variety of flavours and fillings, from seasonal fruit to confectionery.
“I think one of the reasons kakigori has become so popular is because of all the unique and creative toppings and fillings you can enjoy,” Imada says.
“For instance, Japan is known for its amazing fruit, so when you can get shaved ice covered in a sauce made from perfect Japanese strawberries, you know it’s going to be good.”

Jeong Sang-hyub, chef de cuisine at Park Hyatt Seoul, believes the difference is in the toppings and the texture of the ice.
“Bingsu tends to have richer toppings compared to kakigori. While kakigori usually features syrups, smooth sauces or fruits, Korean bingsu often features thick toppings like tteok [rice cakes], red beans, yokan [sweet bean jelly] or large fruit pieces,” he says.
“Additionally, the ice particles in kakigori have a crunchier texture, whereas bingsu ice is finely shaved, melting smoothly in the mouth like snow.”
The origin of shaved ice desserts is a contentious one, with both Japan and Korea laying some claim to its invention.
The Japanese can date the existence of kakigori as far back as the Heian period (794-1185), with it referenced in The Pillow Book, a collection of observations and musings published in 1002 that were recorded by Sei Shonagon during her time as court lady.
However, it is argued that the area from where kakigori originated was Korean territory under Imperial Japan.

What we do know is that the toppings and accoutrements unique to patbingsu – bingsu with red bean, the most common variety – started being noted in Korea from the Joseon dynasty, which began in 1392.
Of course, the spirit of shokunin, or meticulous craftsmanship, that the Japanese are renowned for has been applied to the making of kakigori. A lot can be done with the simple recipe of shaved ice and syrup.
“I found that some [makers] have really thought about how to perfect the texture and the structure of their kakigori,” Imada says. “Some shops have created their own technique to help the ice melt more slowly. One kakigori maker I met said he tries to create a hollow centre to keep [the shaved ice] from melting too quickly.”
The strengths of Korean culture, meanwhile, are its adaptability and aesthetics.
“Korean bingsu also focuses on aesthetic presentation, often enhanced by special performances from the chefs, aiming to provide both visual and gustatory delight,” Jeong says.
“Many younger generations enjoy bingsu not just for its taste but also for its Instagram-worthy appearance, leading to rapidly changing trends that cater to their preferences.”
Recently, mango bingsu has become a trend, especially with the younger generation, who enjoy sharing photos of their desserts on Instagram.












View this post on Instagram























A post shared by ATLANTA KOREATOWN (@atlantakoreatown)



Bingsu is one of the signature menu items at the Park Hyatt Seoul and is one of the hotel’s biggest sellers during summer. Its patbingsu – consisting of a milk base topped with sweet red beans and injeolmi rice cakes covered in roasted soybean powder – is very popular.
However, fruit-flavoured bingsu have become more popular in recent years in tandem with the rise in popularity of Korean fruit.
“We elevate bingsu by using seasonal fruits such as persimmons and cherries, and we have introduced a version made with Jeju apple mango, which has quickly become a favourite among our guests,” Jeong says.
The fact that the icy dessert is served with a side of panoramic city views from The Lounge on the hotel’s 24th floor adds to its popularity, but both Jeong and Imada agree that it is not difficult to enjoy either kakigori or bingsu in the middle of summer.
“Kakigori is not always so fancy,” Imada says. “The classic types you’d find at a festival would be a snow cone with different syrups. That has its own charm, too.”

Jeong says he still remembers eating bingsu with friends after school from a snack shop in an alley on his way home.
“Back then, it was just ice made with water, topped with milk, cheap red beans, jellies and small rice cakes. Though it wasn’t much, the refreshing feeling of eating it on a hot day is a good memory.”


Your Hong Kong weekend drinks guide for June 4-6

Where to go for amazing steak and seafood in Hong Kong? Food influencer reveals

Your Hong Kong weekend food guide for June 5-7

The big scoop: lemon tea chain Ningji to revamp Haagen-Dazs’ struggling China business

Food and Drinks

Japanese kakigori vs Korean bingsu – what’s the best shaved iced dessert for summer?

Mango bingsu, a shaved ice dessert, at the Park Hyatt Seoul hotel. Kakiguri, a Japanese shaved ice dessert, is better known than bingsu, but how do they compare? Photo: Park Hyatt Seoul

The Honey Gold bingsu at Park Hyatt Seoul, in South Korea. Photo: Park Hyatt Seoul

Kaila Imada owns the kakigori-focused Instagram account @kakigori.kaila. Photo: Kaila Imada

Park Hyatt Seoul chef de cuisine Jeong Sang-hyub makes mango bingsu. Photo: Park Hyatt Seoul

The Matcha Cream Special at Shari Shari Kakigori House in Causeway Bay, Hong Kong. Photo: Edmond So

‘Divine’ tiramisu, keto-friendly vegan cakes: wellness expert’s go-to Hong Kong restaurants

Power balls at Suphia’s Functional Foods. Photo: Instagram/@suphias.functional.foods

Power balls at Suphia’s Functional Foods, which also offers keto and vegan cakes, and other items, that are also organic and gluten-free. The shop in Central is one of Cavan Chan’s favourite places to eat in Hong Kong. Photo: Instagram/suphias.functional.foods

Dishes at Orka. Photo: Orka

Farm chicken and fish maw rice noodles with Chinese herbs at Ying Kee Seasonal Healthy Noodle. Photo: Instagram / @dingding.foodie

Cavan Chan looks for dining options that align with his health-conscious philosophy. Photo: Cavan Chan

Her tea cocktails at Indulge Experimental Bistro tell the story of Taiwan: meet Grace Tsai

Grace Tsai at Taipei’s Indulge Experimental Bistro. She will be serving her cocktails that express Taiwanese culture through the use of local teas and other ingredients at a pop-up in Hong Kong. Photo: Indulge Experimental Bistro

Inside Indulge Experimental Bistro in Da’an, Taipei. Photo: Indulge Experimental Bistro

Tsai at Indulge Experimental Bistro, where she makes cocktails that take customers “from our land to the world”. Photo: Indulge Experimental Bistro

Taiwan is known for producing some of the best teas in the world, and Tsai uses many of them in her drinks. Photo: Reuters

Indulge Experimental Bistro’s Flora Vintage cocktail, made with Spirit of Hven Hvenus Rye Whisky, honey, Mancino vermouth and rose. Photo: Indulge Experimental Bistro

The Club Bar and Lounge at Carlyle & Co, where Tsai will be holding a pop-up on July 17 and 18. Photo: Carlyle & Co

What is natto? Just like durian, stinky tofu, the sticky soybean dish is loved or hated

Natto is widely consumed in Japan as a budget superfood, but the fermented soybeans’ pungent aroma and wildly sticky texture are not for everyone. Photo: Shutterstock

A natto course at Natto Sosaku Cuisine Natsumame, a natto-focused restaurant in Kyoto, Japan, by Naoko Natsumi. Photo: Instagram/@natsumame_

Natto is a cat the writer named after the sticky fermented soybeans because of the pattern on her belly. Photo: Charmaine Mok

Natto stirred into pasta in a recipe from Naoko Natsumi. Photo: Instagram/@natsumame_

Eric Räty at Arbor. He is often inspired by Japanese ingredients and techniques. Last year, he added a natto dessert to the menu. Photo: Arbor

A natto-infused sauce is used in Arbor’s fish main course. Photo: Arbor

Ice cream made with toasted natto and oat milk at Arbor. Photo: Arbor

Korean skincare brand Mediheal have a nattogum face mask for sale. Photo: Charmaine Mok

Lifestyle

Food & Drink

We look at the differences between the two treats and why both countries lay claim to the invention of shaved ice desserts


From recipes to serving styles, we look at the differences between Japanese kakigori and Korean bingsu and why both countries claim they are the origin of shaved ice desserts.


South Korea

Japan

Asian Cuisine

Japanese kakigori vs Korean bingsu – what’s the best shaved iced dessert for summer?

.css-1mniedq{color:inherit;font-weight:inherit;font-size:inherit;font-family:inherit;line-height:inherit;}We look at the differences between the two treats and why both countries lay claim to the invention of shaved ice desserts

We look at the differences between the two treats and why both countries lay claim to the invention of shaved ice desserts