In Japan-South Korea trade war, friendly gestures mean it’s worse than ever
- Seoul agreed to extend a military intelligence pact and Tokyo said it would review export controls, but the moves mask an intractable dispute over wartime labour compensation
- Analysts say they are pessimistic that a true detente is near
Seoul also said on Friday it would halt a complaint it filed with the World Trade Organisation over the export controls Japan imposed on three chemicals crucial to South Korea’s microchip industry.
Japan has since announced it would be willing to review the export controls if Seoul meets three conditions: a commitment to continuing bilateral discussions; new measures to strengthen its monitoring of exports of sensitive equipment to third nations and the introduction of new legislation to prohibit its exports from being used to develop weapons in other countries.
And on Wednesday, a proposal was unveiled by Moon Hee-sang, the speaker of the South Korean national assembly, for the creation of a foundation that would accept donations from companies, individuals and the governments of both Japan and South Korea and for the funds to be shared between the victims.
Analysts are not optimistic that the two sides will be able to put aside their differences to reach a lasting agreement, with any “goodwill” generated by Seoul agreeing to extend the intelligence-sharing pact on Friday quickly dissipating in renewed accusations.
Japanese newspapers hinted Abe had prevailed over Moon and the South Korean leader had lost face, while South Korean media hit back, claiming Japanese officials had “apologised” for imposing restrictions on its exports. Tokyo angrily denied having made any such apology, and South Korean government officials protested at Japan “distorting the facts” on Seoul’s decision to renew the GSOMIA pact.
“We haven’t seen the last of Korea-Japan diplomatic recriminations and tough negotiations,” said Leif-Eric Easley, an associate professor of international relations at Ewha Womans University in Seoul.
Seoul to deepen trade with Asean as Japan disputes, tariff war drag on
“A compensation fund needs to be set up in South Korea to pay wartime labour plaintiffs. At the same time, trade security officials from the two countries should determine a process for lifting Tokyo’s export restrictions,” he said. “If discussions fail and Korean authorities liquidate Japanese corporate assets as wartime compensation, Japan’s export controls will really start to hurt the Korean economy.”
If the South’s economy does take a noticeable nose-dive, Koreans are likely to very quickly lay the blame at Japan’s door and rapprochement will be even more distant, he warned.
“Personally, I’m very pessimistic about the relationship,” said Robert Dujarric, a professor of international relations at the Tokyo campus of Temple University.
“On the face of it, the South Korean proposal sounds good, but it would have been far better if this had been put forward before the courts started handing down rulings in favour of the forced labourers,” he said. “At that point, it might have even been possible to get some Japanese companies involved and gained some traction.
“The Japanese plan, on the other hand, sounds like a non-starter because Seoul will not just accept those demands for new laws,” he said.
“I think that there are some on the Japanese side who have realised now that the export restrictions were a mistake – certainly Japanese companies are strongly against them – and there is a growing recognition that they need to find a way out.
“The problem is that there is not an obvious way out and things have gone too far for either side to back down,” Dujarric said. “I do not believe this is going to get to the point where the two countries will actually be fighting each other, but this is going to take a very long time to heal.”
South Korea staying in Japan intelligence pact ‘helps US contain China’
South Korea said on Friday it still has the right to withdraw from the GSOMIA pact at any time, while Japan has said it can keep its trade restrictions in place or, in an escalation of the situation, impose restrictions on more exports.
Ill feeling over the disputes resulted in a two-thirds decline in the number of South Koreans visiting Japan in October. Japan’s exports to South Korea also fell by 23 per cent in October.
Abe and Moon are due to attend three-way talks with China in Chengdu next month, with the South Koreans saying they will attempt to set up a side meeting between both leaders.
Apart from a short meeting on the sidelines of the Asean summit in Thailand earlier in November, they have not had formal talks for more than a year.
Additional reporting by Bloomberg