Japan safety chief under fire for ‘savouring’ eel lunch, then responding to attack on PM Kishida

Koichi Tani, chair of Japan’s National Public Safety Commission, ‘fully savoured and finished’ his lunch of eel rice before responding to attack on Kishida
Tani’s comments sparked criticism over his ‘lack of urgency’ but Kishida and some lawmakers say he handled his duties ‘adequately’

Japan

Associated Press

Published: 7:30pm, 26 Apr 2023

Why you can trust SCMP

Japan’s public safety chief has come under fire for his remark that he enjoyed eel rice so much that he kept eating after his agency informed him of Prime Minister Fumio Kishida’s narrow escape from a pipe bomb attack two weeks ago.

Koichi Tani, chair of the National Public Safety Commission for Kishida’s Cabinet, told a governing party gathering on Tuesday that he had the local delicacy in front of him for lunch when the phone rang.

“I was told that we can eat delicious unagi (eel) rice bowl there, and I was really looking forward to it,” Tani told party lawmakers. “Just as I was going to dig into it, I got a call from the National Police Agency saying something was thrown at the prime minister in Wakayama,” Tani said.

“But I fully savoured and finished … my unadon (eel rice bowl),” he said, beaming.

Attack on Japan’s Kishida shows ‘lessons of Abe’s assassination not learned’

Tani was in the Shimanto area in the southwestern prefecture of Kochi during the attack – about 250 kilometres (150 miles) southwest of Wakayama, where a man threw an explosive device at Kishida as the prime minister was about to make a campaign speech to cheer a local governing party candidate. Kishida was unharmed and the suspect arrested.

The attack on the prime minister came less than a year after former leader Shinzo Abe was killed while delivering a campaign speech. The assassination investigation found holes in police security and led to reinforcement of dignitary protection. Experts, however, said the attack on Kishida raised questions if any lessons were learned from the Abe case.

Tani’s eel comment immediately sparked criticisms and concern at Parliament and on social media about Japan’s public safety as the country makes its final preparations for the Group of Seven (G7) summit that Kishida will host on May 19-21 in Hiroshima. During a parliamentary session, some opposition lawmakers demanded Tani’s dismissal.

A fishing port in the western Japan city of Wakayama, where a man threw an explosive device at Japanese Prime Minister Fumio Kishida as he was about to make a speech on April 15. Remnants of the exploded device were found near a warehouse shown in the lower right part of the screenshot. Photo: Kyodo

“As head of the National Public Safety Commission, (Tani) lacks sense of urgency,” said Jun Azumi, an executive of the main opposition Constitutional Democratic Party of Japan. “Isn’t this a negative for the prime minister to have such a person as chief executive responsible for Japan’s security?”

But Kishida said Tani handled his duties adequately and that he wanted the public safety chief to stay on.

Chief Cabinet Secretary Hirokazu Matsuno also defended Tani. He said the public safety chief, who was in Kochi as the disaster prevention minister, juggled both duties and gave adequate instructions to officials responding to the explosion in Wakayama.

“I also contacted Minister Tani and once again told him to carry out his duties firmly,” Matsuno said.

01:51

Heightened security at G7 meetings after apparent smoke bomb attack on Japanese PM

Tani on Wednesday told reporters he wanted to highlight eel as a local delicacy of the area he visited, but that he had “poorly expressed myself in my brief comment and might have caused misunderstanding – and I must take it seriously”.

“With the G7 summit coming up, I’m aware of the importance of protecting Japan’s public safety, and I will carry out my duty with a sense of alertness,” Tani added.

Kishida told a group of foreign media journalists last week that he planned to improve security before the G7 summit.

Tani is the latest member of Kishida’s government to come under fire over controversial remarks. In November, justice minister Yasuhiro Hanashi resigned after saying his low-profile job only makes news when he places a stamp approving a death penalty. In February, a Kishida aide was dismissed after making homophobic remarks that he did not want to live next door to or see LGBTQ people.

Post