Advertisement
Advertisement
Japan
Get more with myNEWS
A personalised news feed of stories that matter to you
Learn more
Transcripts from flight recorders revealed that a Japan Airlines passenger jet had permission to land before colliding with a coastguard aircraft on the runway at Tokyo’s Haneda airport. Photo: TNS

Japan plane collision: transcript shows crashed plane entered runway without permission; passenger jet authorised to land

  • Transcripts of traffic control instructions released by authorities appeared to show the Japan Airlines passenger plane had been given permission to land
  • But the coastguard aircraft had been told to taxi to a holding point near the runway, contradicting a statement from the captain of the coastguard plane
Japan
Japanese authorities said on Wednesday that a passenger jet that collided with a coastguard turboprop at a Tokyo airport was given permission to land, but the smaller plane was not cleared for take-off, based on transcripts of conversations with the control tower.

All 379 people aboard the Japan Airlines (JAL) Airbus A350 had a miraculous escape after it erupted in flames following Tuesday’s crash with a De Havilland Dash-8 coastguard turboprop shortly after landing at Haneda airport.

But five died among the six coastguard crew who were due to depart on a flight responding to a major earthquake on the west coast, while the captain, who escaped the wreckage, was badly injured.

Authorities have only just begun their investigations and there remains uncertainty over the circumstances surrounding the incident, including how the two aircraft ended up on the same runway.

Officials look at the burnt wreckage of a Japan Airlines (JAL) passenger plane on the tarmac at Tokyo International Airport at Haneda in Tokyo on Wednesday. Photo: AFP
But transcripts of traffic control instructions released by authorities appeared to show the Japan Airlines plane had been given permission to land, but that the coastguard aircraft had been told to taxi to a holding point near the runway.

The Transport Ministry released a transcript of air traffic control communication of about 4 minutes and 27 seconds just before the crash. It showed no clear take-off approval for the coastguard plane. According to the text, the Tokyo air control gave the JAL Airbus A350 permission to land on Runway C, noting that there is a departing plane, with the JAL pilot repeating the action.

The coastguard plane said it was taxiing to the same runway, and the traffic control instructs it to proceed to the stop line ahead of the runway. The controller noted the coastguard gets the departure priority, and the pilot said he was moving to the stop line.

Their communication ends there. Two minutes later, there was a three-second pause, apparently indicating the time of the collision.

02:31

Five killed after coastguard plane collides with Japan Airlines passenger jet at Haneda airport

Five killed after coastguard plane collides with Japan Airlines passenger jet at Haneda airport

The captain of the coastguard plane said he had entered the runway after receiving permission, a coastguard official said, while acknowledging that there was no indication in the transcripts that he had been cleared to do so.

Police began a separate investigation into possible professional negligence. Tokyo police said investigators examined the debris on the runway and were conducting interviews.

“The transport ministry is submitting objective material and will fully cooperate with the … investigation to ensure we work together to take all possible safety measures to prevent a recurrence,” Transport Minister Tetsuo Saito told reporters.

The Japan Safety Transport Board (JTSB) is investigating the incident, with participation by agencies in France, where the Airbus aeroplane was built, and Britain, where its two Rolls-Royce engines were made, people familiar with the matter said.

The JTSB has recovered the voice recorder from the coastguard aircraft, authorities said.

Japan Airlines said on Thursday it estimated the operating loss amount will be about 15 billion yen (US$104.81 million). The loss will be covered by the insurance, the company said.

Meanwhile, Tokyo police are investigating whether possible professional negligence led to deaths and injuries, several media, including Kyodo and the Nikkei business newspaper, said.

There’s a strong possibility there was a human error
Hiroyuki Kobayash, former JAL pilot

Police set up a special unit at the airport to investigate and planned to interview those involved, a spokesperson said, but declined to say if they were examining the negligence concerns.

“There’s a strong possibility there was a human error,” said aviation analyst Hiroyuki Kobayashi, who is a former JAL pilot.

“Aircraft accidents very rarely occur due to a single problem, so I think that this time too there were two or three issues that led to the accident.”

In a statement on Wednesday, JAL said the aircraft recognised and repeated the landing permission from air traffic control before approaching and touching down.

Japanese transport minister Tetsuo Saito (C) arrives at the prime minister’s office in Tokyo on Tuesday following a collision between a Japan Airlines Co. plane and a Japan Coast Guard aircraft at the capital’s Haneda airport. Photo: Kyodo

All passengers and crew were evacuated within 20 minutes of the crash, but the aircraft, engulfed in flames, burned for more than six hours, the airline said.

The coastguard aircraft, one of six based at the airport, had been due to deliver aid to regions hit by Monday’s earthquake of magnitude 7.6 that has killed 64, while survivors face freezing temperatures and prospects of heavy rain.

The accident forced the cancellation of 137 domestic, and four international, flights on Wednesday, the government said.

But emergency flights and high-speed rail services have been requested to ease the congestion, Transport Minister Saito said.

5