Advertisement
US, Israel war on Iran
OpinionWorld Opinion
Macroscope
Nicholas Spiro

Reopening Strait of Hormuz won’t fix world’s energy problems

As energy security becomes a more potent force, stress tests for countries vulnerable to supply disruptions are likely to become more severe

3-MIN READ3-MIN
Listen
Students clash with police officers during a protest against a fuel price hike in Jakarta on June 12. Photo: EPA
Nicholas Spiro is a partner at Lauressa Advisory, a specialist London-based real estate and macroeconomic advisory firm.
It is easy to lose count of the number of times US President Donald Trump said he was close to a deal with Iran. The announcement on June 14 by both the United States and Iran of a preliminary agreement to end their nearly four-month war and reopen the Strait of Hormuz appears to be more credible.
Stock markets staged a relief rally while Brent crude, the international oil benchmark, has dropped to US$78 a barrel, only slightly above its level when the war erupted on February 28. There are still many unanswered questions given the lack of clarity on the reopening of the strait, particularly what restrictions will remain in place and who will regulate shipping traffic. However, it appears investors stopped worrying about the conflict in the Middle East some time ago.

Robin Brooks of the Brookings Institution said, “Both sides have an interest in ending this war permanently. That’s good and says oil prices should fall farther and faster.” Yet the 14-point memorandum of understanding, which is expected to be formally signed by Washington and Tehran in Geneva on June 19, looks more like an affirmation of the uncertainty and risks in energy markets.

Advertisement

The reopening of the waterway, a critical energy chokepoint, presents a huge logistical challenge regardless of the timing of the resumption of transit through the strait. Some of the most pressing challenges include mine clearance, insurance reinstatement and restarting idled production fields in several Gulf states.

“Under a more cautious scenario reflecting partial implementation or delays, [the fourth quarter] would be a more realistic time frame for flows recovering to 70 per cent or more of pre-conflict levels,” HSBC said in a June 15 report.

Advertisement
Oil prices were never a reliable and accurate gauge of the impact of the energy shock. Brent crude has traded below US$100 a barrel since late May despite the persistent threat of renewed hostilities between the US and Iran. This is partly because of the unprecedented drawdown of global inventories and emergency reserves, especially in the US, where stockpiles have fallen to their lowest level since 1983.
Advertisement
Select Voice
Select Speed
1.00x