Advertisement
Advertisement
Coronavirus pandemic
Get more with myNEWS
A personalised news feed of stories that matter to you
Learn more
Commuters wait to leave the Woodlands Causeway across to Singapore from Johor, hours before Malaysia imposes a lockdown on travel. Photo: Reuters

Aggressive tracing, lessons from Sars: how Singapore is flattening the coronavirus curve

  • The city state’s strong ability to trace, detect and isolate patients have helped to put it ahead of other countries in containing the coronavirus
  • While Singapore is not under lockdown, experts say such a move may also help to flatten the curve for other countries, as it did for China’s Wuhan city

Singaporean coronavirus patient Adam – not his real name – returned from an 11-day trip to France and Spain on March 7, but after he went back to work two days later, he started developing a sore throat.

The 27-year-old decided it was best to see a doctor and work from home on March 10 – the same day France and Spain reported 286 and 435 coronavirus cases, respectively.

“On Tuesday morning when I woke up, my temperature was still OK, but I had a hunch, so I went to the GP and emailed my colleagues to say I was going to the doctor and working from home,” Adam said.

Despite Adam’s mild symptoms, doctors were concerned about his travel history and sent him to Singapore’s National Centre for Infectious Diseases (NCID) to be tested.

Coronavirus: Singapore PM says pandemic could last a year

By March 11, Adam was confirmed as Singapore’s 171st coronavirus patient and he was hospitalised for five days. He was discharged on March 16.

Throughout his stay at the hospital, he only had a sore throat and runny nose that was treated with regular medication: flu pills, paracetamol, Vitamin C and lozenges.

The moment the race started, Singapore ran but the other countries were just getting ready.
Leong Hoe Nam, infectious disease expert

Shawn Vasoo, clinical director at NCID, told This Week in Asia that the illness for many of Singapore’s virus patients would result in a fever that would eventually resolve itself.

“After the fever disappears, some coughing may continue. So far, the runny noses and sore throats have been quite mild. The patients may have an occasional cough, but it is quite uncommon for them to be constantly coughing. Many reported coughing as a result of itchy throat,” he said.

Vasoo said those with mild coughs or sore throats would take about one week to recover, while those with pneumonia – about 40 per cent of the patients – would take 10 to 14 days.

“But if they have respiratory failure and need to go to the intensive care unit (ICU), it can take several weeks to get back to normal,” he said.

A worker takes the temperature of a visitor at the entrance of a library in Singapore, March 3, 2020. Photo: EPA-EFE

Singapore has been treating patients in intensive care with supplemental oxygen and, if required, mechanical ventilation while their lung function recovers. Most are also treated with antiviral drugs such as lopinavir-ritonavir, which is used in treatment for HIV.

In the almost 60 days since Singapore confirmed its first patient on January 23, the country has 385 cases of Covid-19 and 131 have fully recovered. On Saturday, it reported its first two deaths. The observations from Vasoo are based on 82 patients at the NCID.

Singapore, Hong Kong, Taiwan: the real Covid-19 world leaders

Earlier this month, the city state had one of the highest recovery rates for coronavirus patients until it saw a spike in imported cases – between March 10 and 19, a total of 126 travellers returned and tested positive for the Covid-19 illness.

Authorities have since told residents to not travel if they can help it, and ordered all incoming travellers to be quarantined for 14 days.

Health economist Phua Kai Hong said: “We’re constantly looking and calibrating accordingly. Some people may think it is a bit draconian, but to me, it is systematic.”

Commuters wear face masks on a train in Singapore on March 18, 2020. Photo: AFP

FLATTENING THE CURVE

Singapore, which has a population of 5.7 million people, has won praise for controlling the spread of the infection. Its infection rate is slow compared to other countries.

Italy’s cases saw a 200-fold increase within 23 days, going from 155 to 31,506 infections among its population of 60.5 million people. In Germany, which has 82.7 million people, cases spiked by 70 times – from 130 to 9,257 – in just 16 days.

Iran’s cases rose to more than 20,000 since its first reported infection on February 19, with its death toll hitting 1,556 on Saturday. Last week, its health ministry spokesman Kianush Jahanpur said on Twitter that based on information it had, “every 10 minutes, one person dies from the coronavirus and some 50 people become infected with the virus every hour in Iran”.

From Sars to Covid-19, what lessons has Singapore learned?

Singapore’s ability to flatten the curve – public health expert speak for slowing the rate of infections to ensure hospitals are not overwhelmed – has been attributed to its aggressive tracing and containment methods and top-notch health care system.

Infectious disease expert Leong Hoe Nam said when details of the outbreak emerged from mainland China at the end of December last year, places such as Singapore, Taiwan and Hong Kong readied themselves.
“The severe acute respiratory syndrome (Sars) outbreak gave us the experience and it was a blessing,” he said.

“When we had our first case, we traced contacts aggressively so we could quickly isolate them. The moment the race started, Singapore ran but the other countries were just getting ready,” he said. “You see that happening in the US, UK and Europe. Once there were cases, they couldn’t detect, isolate and quarantine fast enough.”

Singapore was among the first countries to bar foreign arrivals from China. Photo: EPA-EFE
Singapore was one of the first countries to ban all travellers except its citizens and residents from Hubei province when the outbreak peaked there, and just days after it included the whole of China in the travel restriction. This then expanded to South Korea, Italy and Iran as the infection moved out of China, and was later adjusted to include Germany, Spain and France as the disease spread across Europe.

Singapore on Sunday announced that it will ban all short-term visitors from entering or transiting through the city state indefinitely, starting Monday.

South Korea’s virus response is the opposite of China’s – and it works

Every time a case is confirmed, authorities will leap into tracing close contacts, asking infected patients questions such as “Who did you meet? What did you do? Did you share food?”.

Officers from the police’s criminal investigation department have been roped in to conduct investigations into contacts, with CCTV footage and data visualisations used as well.

The government on Friday also launched an app called TraceTogether that uses Bluetooth technology to note down the close contacts of citizens – people whom they have come within 2 metres of and spent at least 30 minutes with.

All infected patients have been hospitalised, those deemed at high risk of contracting the illness are quarantined, while others who are potentially exposed are ordered to stay home for 14 days. Flouting either orders can result in a fine of up to S$10,000 (US$6,900) and/or six months in jail.

The city state freed up government chalets and school hostels to be used as quarantine sites, and postponed elective surgeries at public hospitals so the focus could be on Covid-19 patients.

When foreigners in the region started going to the Lion City to be treated for the coronavirus, the country reversed its policy of waiving treatment fees for foreigners to curtail the strain on its health care system.
Singapore launched TraceTogether, a contact-tracing smartphone app, on March 20, 2020. Photo: AFP
Associate professor Hsu Li Yang, the programme leader for infectious diseases at the National University of Singapore’s Saw Swee Hock School of Public Health, said this flexibility and resolution in public health interventions was crucial in slowing the spread of the coronavirus.

Managing this strain on the health care system was important because while most Covid-19 patients showed mild symptoms and could recover while resting at home – an option if hospitals were not able to provide isolation rooms for them – some had respiratory failure and would need critical care.

The ability of countries to keep patients alive are constrained by their number of ICU beds and equipment such as the extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (Ecmo), which pumps and oxygenates blood outside the patient’s body, allowing the heart and lungs to rest.

Hong Kong, Singapore seen as safe harbours as global virus cases rise

Infectious diseases expert Leong said about 11 per cent of patients would need oxygen that could be given in general wards of hospitals and nine per cent would need critical care. The remaining 80 per cent would most likely be able to recover at home.

As of last year, Singapore had 11,321 hospital beds in private and public hospitals, with Leong estimating that about 300 were ICU beds.

According to US media reports, modelling by the US Centres for Disease Control and Prevention show that between 2.4 million and 21 million people could require hospitalisation, potentially crushing the nation’s medical system, which has about 925,000 staffed hospital beds including 95,000 ICU beds.

WUHAN-STYLE LOCKDOWNS?

Leaders in the West have been accused of not taking the virus threat seriously enough, with delayed action leading to alarming surges in global infections, that grew to more than 234,000 on Friday. Two-thirds of the close to 10,000 deaths from the virus have taken place outside China and the number of deaths in Italy surpassed China’s 3,248 this week.

China, which has been criticised for missteps that allowed the virus to spread, locked down Hubei province where infections were first reported, built new temporary hospitals and tested suspected cases aggressively. After a three-month battle, by this week it was reporting no new local infections, with new cases coming from travellers who had been abroad.

Western countries have been wary of such a tough approach, though Italy is under a national lockdown, with people only allowed to leave home to get essential services. Malaysia and the Philippines have placed restrictions on peoples’ movements and shut down businesses.
People queue to buy food and groceries at a supermarket in Singapore on March 17, 2020. Photo: EPA-EFE

While Singapore’s schools and businesses are still running – although some firms have asked staff to work from home – the country is ramping up social distancing measures. On Friday, it announced that at all public venues, people would have to maintain a distance of one metre from each other, among other steps.

Experts say more drastic restrictions could be the way to go.

“The best example of this is Wuhan in China,” Hsu said, referring to the city in Hubei province.

Despite the large number of cases in Wuhan, most of the Chinese population had not been infected. “The curve has also been flattened there.”

Leong agreed. “You’ve to do it the Wuhan way,” he said. “So you literally have to restrict everyone’s movement in and out of the house.”

Leong said this would stop the community spread of the virus, which has a 14-day incubation period, because in the first seven to 10 days, those who fell ill could be taken out of their homes and quarantined.

“In the next seven to 10 days, family members who fall sick in the second cycle can also be taken out for quarantine,” he said.

“By the third [cycle of] seven to 10 days, those who did not fall sick are clear of the virus. So in about two months, the situation will be quite safe. Now people in Wuhan are free to go around again,” he said.

“If you have the resources to enforce a strict lockdown, which many first-world countries do, then you should just do it. It is either two months of pain, or you let it burn on for one to two, and even three years.”

Purchase the China AI Report 2020 brought to you by SCMP Research and enjoy a 20% discount (original price US$400). This 60-page all new intelligence report gives you first-hand insights and analysis into the latest industry developments and intelligence about China AI. Get exclusive access to our webinars for continuous learning, and interact with China AI executives in live Q&A. Offer valid until 31 March 2020.

Post