Advertisement
HSBC
This Week in AsiaOpinion
Neil Newman

Abacus | Caught in US-China crossfire, should HSBC split its global businesses?

  • Having become a political football, ‘the world’s local bank’ might do better to rethink its global vision and split into separate listings in Hong Kong and London
  • Breaking up is hard to do, but it may be the only way to win investors back

Reading Time:6 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
The London offices of HSBC in the Canary Wharf district of London. Photo: AFP

BREAKING UP THE BANK

Holding HSBC shares has been a disaster for investors over the past year. Its share price has nearly halved as the bank was dragged into politics, pushed to take sides in the falling-out between the United States and China, and with its British headquarters told to “toe the line” by joining British banks in not paying investors dividends this year. That last point especially shakes the very core of Hong Kong investors’ investment thesis for the beloved HSBC shares, leaving 0005.HK in a very weak position.

First, a little backstory on the sixth-biggest bank in the world by assets, and the largest one headquartered in London. It was founded on “sound Scottish banking principles” in British Hong Kong in 1865, and incorporated a year later as the Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation. That year, it also opened a branch in Yokohama, and it quickly became the cornerstone of Hong Kong and Asian regional finance. It is one of only a handful of retail banks in the world that are trusted to print physical banknotes for circulation – there are two others in Hong Kong, two in Scotland and four in Northern Ireland.
Advertisement
In 1992, it bought Midland Bank in Britain, a high-profile high-street bank, in a move to become a household name. Midland Bank’s golden griffin logo had gone completely seven years later, with HSBC and its prominent red hexagon in just about every high street in the UK.

With its reliable dividend it was a favourite for Hong Kong investors, for whom the “rule of thumb” has been that if the shares are below HK$60 (closing Friday at HK$33.10, -1.05 per cent on heavy volume), you buy them and give them to your children and grandchildren – safe as houses and good as gold. But over the past 20 years, the bank has been involved in a series of scandals that would have its founder, Scotsman Thomas Sutherland, turning in his grave.

02:05

HSBC sees second-quarter profits plunge by 82 per cent thanks to coronavirus

HSBC sees second-quarter profits plunge by 82 per cent thanks to coronavirus

THE U.S. CONTROLS DOLLAR ACCESS FOR HSBC – AND EVERY OTHER BANK

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x