Letters | Why Hong Kong protesters must give up anti-China nationalism
- Hatred of China and all things Chinese is fuelling the protest violence in Hong Kong
- By aiming their fury at the ‘outsider’, radical protesters will only ensure that the many reasonable demands of the anti-government movement go unheard
Growing up in Spain, I am no stranger to nationalism. For years nationalist parties have poisoned Spain’s public discourse and turned it into an endless battle where ethnic origin, rather than solutions, defines every political conversation. In recent months, the international community has caught a glimpse of Spain’s own internal struggles with nationalism as it fights to contain Catalonia’s separatist movement.
I believe that denouncing a government’s administrative incompetence does not amount to a justification for independence, but such grievances are far from what is currently fuelling the movement’s desire to break away from Spain.
The more you listen to their demands, a pattern all too familiar begins to emerge. They will complain about how los de fuera (outsiders) are coming in, taking their jobs, speaking a language that they don’t consider to be their own. Sound familiar?
Needless to say, nationalism values identity above all else. It appeals to our most primal, and dangerous, inner emotions, forcing us to let go of reason, engulfing our judgment in a cloud of hatred against those we deem to be inferior because of their origin.
The dirty secret of Hong Kong’s protests: hatred of mainlanders
It is clear to me that the violence currently plaguing the streets of Hong Kong carries the banner of localised nationalism. It is no longer “concerned citizens versus unacceptable legislation”. It is “Hong Kong versus anything Chinese”, and it is frightening.
If anything, the 20th century should have taught us that nationalism is never the answer. Nationalist ideas function as a channel for individuals to vent their anger, often at those who are different, but offer no solutions and almost always lead to tragedy.
Spain’s PM under pressure as separatists copy Hong Kong protest tactics
Don’t get me wrong. Many of the city’s anti-government protesters have made several good points. Like them, I believe that the Hong Kong government should follow through on its old promise to implement universal suffrage. I also believe that the government should be more transparent when investigating potential cases of police brutality, and that Hong Kong should take every step necessary to ensure that everyone, and not just the ultra rich, has a shot at leading a worry-free life in the city they call home.
Cesar Lardies Rivas, Sham Shui Po