Advertisement
Advertisement
Hong Kong society
Get more with myNEWS
A personalised news feed of stories that matter to you
Learn more
The whale carcass is buried near the High Island Reservoir west dam on August 8. Photo: Sam Tsang

Letters | Turn whale remains into a monument of Hong Kong shame

  • Readers discuss what it takes to teach marine life protection to Hongkongers, academia’s role in the world today, and university campus access
Feel strongly about these letters, or any other aspects of the news? Share your views by emailing us your Letter to the Editor at [email protected] or filling in this Google form. Submissions should not exceed 400 words, and must include your full name and address, plus a phone number for verification.
Experts have completed a necropsy on the Sai Kung whale. Although the cause of death has not been officially revealed, Philip Wong, general curator of zoological operations and conservation at Ocean Park, said a new wound found on the whale was likely caused by a vessel. Was this murder or whale-slaughter?

The Agriculture, Fisheries and Conservation Department said it hoped the whale skeleton could eventually be turned into a specimen for education and conservation purposes. However, the Bryde’s whale would not be the city’s first whale specimen.

Those who have been to Cape D’Aguilar have probably seen the skeleton of the juvenile male fin whale that turned up in Victoria Harbour in 1955. The skeleton was erected in 1991 for education and conservation purposes. However, recent events should have shown that just looking at a whale skeleton is not enough for Hongkongers to learn about marine life protection.
Despite serving as a popular Instagram and photography spot for years, the whale skeleton has clearly failed to educate us about conservation. What more can be done? There have been suggestions that boats should be banning from going near whales and that a restricted area should be established to protect wild animals in similar situations.

However, whale movement might be unpredictable. It seems difficult to determine the best size of such a restricted area, especially if it covers busy channels. Therefore, education should be the key to preventing such a tragedy from happening again.

02:19

Hong Kong buries Bryde’s whale found dead after days feeding off Hong Kong waters

Hong Kong buries Bryde’s whale found dead after days feeding off Hong Kong waters

We should all be educated on common-sense marine life protection such as not getting too close to these animals just for the sake of snapping photos. Many people “do it for the ’gram”, but that does not mean animals should die “for the ’gram”.

How can we learn from this incident? Perhaps the Bryde’s whale skeleton could be showcased at Sai Kung pier as a memorial. The sign should clearly state that the whale was found dead in Hong Kong waters in July 2023, following visits by overexcited whale watchers in vessels that got extremely close to it.

This way, the whale will not have died in vain. Its death will be made a reminder of our shameful behaviour, and every photo of the memorial will be a warning of the dangers of overexuberant social media posts, chasing likes and cheap gratification.

Christopher Ip, North Point

World’s universities can advocate for change together

Recently, I had the privilege of attending the World University Presidents Forum in Beijing, where I spoke on how academia can play a crucial role in addressing the world’s pressing challenges.

In confronting critical issues such as climate change, income inequality, geopolitical tensions and food security, there are four key areas on which academia must focus its efforts.

Firstly, the establishment of a collaborative framework is crucial. We need to create a platform that fosters collaboration and knowledge sharing beyond national boundaries and political positions, enabling seamless cooperation among institutions worldwide. This framework should facilitate joint research projects, exchange programmes and sharing of best practices, thus enhancing the collective impact of universities.

Secondly, the importance of aligning research efforts must be emphasised. Universities’ primary mission is to generate knowledge and contribute to society. By aligning our research endeavours with real-world problems, we can surely produce impactful outputs that make a tangible difference.

Thirdly, we must encourage all regional and national alliances of academics to integrate discussions and actions related to global challenges. Thus, we can form a unified front that amplifies academia’s collective impact.

Lastly, universities must adopt a proactive approach to policymaking and advocacy. Our research strengths and intellectual capabilities uniquely position us to influence policy decisions and advocate for meaningful change. Engagement with international organisations such as the United Nations and the World Economic Forum ensures that our insights are heard and can contribute to both existing and new policy frameworks.

I firmly believe that the forum marks the beginning of a transformative era for academia, united in purpose and vision.

Professor Mohd Hamdi Abd Shukor, vice-chancellor, Universiti Malaya

City University should rethink its campus access policy

With the end of the Covid-19 pandemic, while most universities in Hong Kong have reopened their campuses to the public, City University continues to control access. Visitors need QR codes, and staff and students must present ID cards to enter the campus, causing inconvenience and wasting manpower.

Such a campus access policy, while intended for safety, hinders academic exchange and undermines the university’s role as an intellectual hub. For example, it becomes inconvenient for holders of JULAC (Joint University Librarians Advisory Committee) cards from other public-funded universities to visit the university’s library.

I call on the University Grants Committee and the Legislative Council to review the policy and persuade CityU to balance safety with its commitment to open exchange and public accountability.

Simon Wang, Kowloon Tong

4