Five of the best chocolate chip cookies in Hong Kong, from Pret to Mrs Fields, and what makes them so delicious

Taina Puddefoot

Does a $40 treat taste better than a $7 one? Is Eric Kayser's chunky delight better than Subway's classic cookie? YP cadets conduct a blind taste test to determine the best biscuit in the city.

Taina Puddefoot |

Latest Articles

Hong Kong's Covid-19 social distancing measures extended

Our cadets did a blind taste test to determine which was the best chocolate chip cookie in Hong Kong.

Baked goods lovers would certainly have an opinion on which brand sells the best cookies, but might their preferences be swayed if we put them to a blind taste test? In honour of Chocolate Chip Cookie Day, we asked our cadets (it didn’t take much convincing) to taste five of the most popular chocolate chip cookies in Hong Kong, blindfolded, and rate them out of five. Here’s the verdict:

Pret a Manger

Like Mrs Fields, Pret cookies are well-suited to our hectic city lives, as they are situated in a number of MTR stations. And, like at Subway, their cookies are nice and crisp on the outside and gooey in the middle when eaten fresh. Our cadets marked them down for their sweetness, but at less than HK$10 each, you can’t really complain!

Price: HK$7

Average rating: 4/5

Mrs Fields

The alluring smell of Mrs Fields’ cookies never fails to tempt us as we pass it on our frantic commutes through MTR stations. Their chocolate chip cookies are deliciously chewy and are the perfect cure to your sugar craving. They make a decent on-the-go treat but the size of the cookies is a bit stingy, considering the price you pay.

Price: HK$15

Average rating: 4/5

Bake your own mooncakes this Mid-Autumn Festival: we’ve got three recipes to help you out

Cookie Department

A cross between a brownie and a cookie, this fist-sized treat is generously packed with large chunks of chocolate, which keep it soft and gooey even hours after buying it. Despite being sinfully cake-like, our cadets found it too heavy and costly for a single cookie.

Price: HK$40

Average rating: 4/5


Whether you’re adding a cookie to your meal deal or simply could not resist the lure of the cookie display rack, Subway’s chocolate chip cookies are a definite crowd-pleaser. Depending on when you go, you might get a stale one, but if you happen upon a fresh batch, they’re tough to beat. Crispy on the edges and chewy in the centre, this cookie scored the highest rating by all the cadets.

Price: HK$8, or three for HK$18

Average rating: 4.5/5

Eric Kayser

This bakery is known for its French traditional breads, but little did we know they also serve up the chunkiest cookies in the market. Although the nuttiness of the cookies proved a little overwhelming for our cadets, the nuts provided all the flavour and texture you could pack into one little cookie. These cookies can stay molten for hours, probably because of the load of chocolate chips and nuts packed into them.

Price: HK$25

Average rating: 3.5/5

Edited by Nicole Moraleda