Face Off: Does Hong Kong complain too much?

Published: 
Listen to this article
  • Each week, two of our readers debate a hot topic in a showdown that does not necessarily reflect their personal viewpoints
  • This week, they debate whether people in the city have a negative attitude and love to criticise too much
YP Readers |
Published: 
Comment

Latest Articles

‘The Garfield Movie’ is a forgettable, unfunny animated slog

Hong Kong university orientation camps need more supervision, lawmakers say

Nasa’s Ingenuity helicopter has sent final message from red planet to Earth

Science competition recognises student innovations that integrate testing

Hong Kong students need more encouragement to study Chinese history, says expert

Does Hong Kong complain too much? What do you think? Photo: Shutterstock

If you are interested in joining future Face Off debates, fill out this form to submit your application.

For: Adrian Chan, 13, St Joseph’s College

Adrian Chan from St Joseph’s College. Photo: Handout

Hong Kong is a bustling city with a fast-paced lifestyle. In the past it has been called both a food and shopping paradise, but a new label has recently emerged: “the city of complaint”. From faulty goods to poor customer service, Hong Kong residents seem to have much to complain about regarding their shopping experiences.

According to the Consumer Council’s annual summary for 2022, complaints made to the agency rose seven per cent last year compared with 2021. They received a total of 28,338 complaints in 2022, up from 26,506 in 2021. A majority of them concerned the food and entertainment industry, electrical appliances, and telecommunications services.

One of the most common criticisms about Hong Kong is its poor customer service. The city is notorious for its often rude and unhelpful staff, which can make shopping a frustrating experience. This is particularly true in the case of telecom companies, which can be known for their long wait times and confusing billing practices.

Hong Kong’s telecoms companies are not known for their excellent customer service. Photo: Shutterstock

Another issue consumers face in Hong Kong is poor product quality. Many report purchasing items that are faulty or do not work as advertised, only to find that they cannot return them or receive a refund. This is often due to the lack of consumer protection laws in Hong Kong, which means that businesses are not held to the same standards as in other countries.

Furthermore, Hong Kong’s high cost of living exacerbates the complaint problem. With the price of goods and services constantly on the rise, residents are becoming increasingly frustrated when they spend their hard-earned money on low-quality products. This is particularly true for essential items such as food and housing, which is often prohibitively expensive.

The government increased minimum wage to HK$40 an hour - but is it enough?

There are some steps that Hong Kong consumers can take to protect themselves. It is important to research products and services before making a purchase and to read reviews from other customers. Additionally, shoppers can make use of the Consumer Council, which provides advice and assistance to those who have experienced problems with businesses.

Hong Kong may be a city of complaints from a consumer perspective. However, by being aware of the challenges and taking steps to protect themselves, people can still enjoy the many benefits the city offers.

Against: Sophia Ling, 11, German Swiss International School

Sophia Ling from German Swiss International School. Photo: Handout

Hong Kong is often labelled a “city of complaint,” insinuating its residents are excessively vocal about their grievances and concerns.

However, this perception is inaccurate and not supported by empirical evidence. Hongkongers enjoy a high quality of life, are generally happy, and are not big complainers.

First of all, Hong Kong has a low crime rate compared to other major cities worldwide, according to the Hong Kong Police Force. The city is generally considered to be safe and secure. This suggests that the general level of dissatisfaction and frustration is not high enough to result in significant levels of crime or violence.

Will the ‘Hello Hong Kong’ campaign help revive tourism?

Furthermore, international surveys consistently rank Hong Kong highly regarding our quality of life. In the 2019 Mercer Quality of Living Survey, Hong Kong ranked 71st out of 231 cities worldwide, ahead of other major cities such as Taipei, Dubai, and Busan. This indicates that residents generally enjoy a high quality of life compared to other cities, and people with a good life don’t have much to complain about.

Moreover, Hong Kong has a highly developed and open economy. It is a major financial and business hub, attracting a large number of international companies and professionals. According to the World Bank, Hong Kong has a high-income and competitive economy. This indicates that the city provides ample opportunities for its residents to pursue their careers and enjoy a high standard of living.

People in Hong Kong generally enjoy a high standard of living . Photo: Shutterstock

The perception of Hong Kong as a “city of complaint” may stem from the significant number of grievances received by the government each year. However, many of these complaints are routine or minor in nature, often related to noise or litter. It is unfair to suggest that this makes Hong Kong a city of unsatisfied people, as citizens have a fundamental right to express their opinions and concerns.

In conclusion, Hong Kong is not a city of complaint, and evidence suggests that residents are generally content with their lives. Hong Kong is not perfect, but people are overall happy and satisfied in our city.

Sign up for the YP Teachers Newsletter
Get updates for teachers sent directly to your inbox
By registering, you agree to our T&C and Privacy Policy
Comment