‘The Vanishing Trick’ book review: magic and mystery combine in a setting worthy of Charles Dickens

  • Leander is an Oliver Twist-type orphan, scrounging a living in a Victorian city
  • Expert plotting and characterisation and a deliciously horrifying villain make this a must-read
John Millen |

Latest Articles

Buckingham Palace staff member resigns after comments to Black exec

Hong Kong could face bigger flu outbreak this winter due to weakened immunity amid Covid

How film and TV can help change attitudes on climate change

Elon Musk’s Twitter lifts rule against Covid misinformation

The Vanishing Trick


By Jenni Spangler

Published by Simon and Schuster

ISBN 978 1 4711 9037 7

It’s a rare debut novel that turns out to be as original, masterful and enthralling as Jenni Spangler’s The Vanishing Trick. This spooky tale is a stand-out in the often overcrowded field of magical youngsters.

Leander is an Oliver Twist-type street orphan, scrounging, and stealing, and sleeping in alleys and shop doorways in a gothic Victorian setting. He doesn’t enjoy stealing, but it is the only way he can survive.

One day, he meets a kind, aristocratic lady called Madame Pinchbeck who offers him food and shelter. Without asking any questions, Leander accepts this generous offer and climbs into her coach. If this move makes you roll your eyes or slap your forehead, you’ve got an idea of what comes next.

A school trip to a new campsite turns out to be far scarier than anyone could have imagined

It turns out that Pinchbeck is a fortune-teller, and she wants Leander’s help her when she stages seances to contact the dead.

Leander soon discovers that Pinchbeck’s only real interest in him is the one treasured possession he owns, a locket that his mother gave him before she died. But what value could this seemingly worthless family trinket have for her?

Leander doesn’t have much choice in the matter: Pinchbeck casts a magic spell which turns the unsuspecting street urchin into a spirit, and imprisons him inside the locket. She only brings him out in human form when she needs him during a performance.

Is Wilde’s new home town filled with pranksters, or do witches still exist?

Pinchbeck has captured many children before, and when she no longer has any use for them, she smashes the “cabinet” in which she has imprisoned them, ending their existence. Leander discovers that the scheming psychic currently has two other children at her command: a boy called Felix who is desperate to find his missing brother, and a girl called Charlotte who has been taken from the home of her wealthy uncle.

Once Spangler has her four main characters in place, it’s a race against time for the three children to escape from Pinchbeck’s clutches and put a stop to her bogus seances and evil plans.

Our top picks for books of the month for July

The desperate trio discover that while Each of them is essential to Pinchbeck’s schemes, she does not have enough power to keep all three of them prisoner. Can they escape, or but will their attempts lead to their own demise?

The Vanishing Trick is a triumph because of its fantastic plot, Spangler’s expert characterisation, and the satisfactory, but far-from-predictable, ending. The seance scenes are genuinely spine-tingling, and in Pinchbeck, there is a memorable, horrifying villain.

This suspenseful magical thriller is a five-star dark tale from an outstanding talent. Highly recommended.

Sign up for the YP Teachers Newsletter
Get updates for teachers sent directly to your inbox
By registering, you agree to our T&C and Privacy Policy